a close shave with 'Make me a Christian'
// August 10th, 2008 // TV
So a few months ago a member of our congregation – Tracey – called me up to say she’d been accepted to appear on an ITV documentary about people of different faiths who were trying to find the perfect partner via faith based dating sites… very odd! But after meeting with the ITV crew and seeing that they just wanted to show Tracey in her church environment we agreed to let them film… everything went really well as I mentioned in my previous post.
The bizarre thing was that about a week later I got a call from some Reverend who was working with a Channel 4 company on a new programme and they wanted to film in our church too. At first I thought it was a joke! Someone from our Sheffield congregation (mainly the senior pastor who is the ultimate prankster) but as it turned out it was a genuine programme. So we chatted about the possibilities but the more I chatted with them the more I thought – this thing sounds really odd. From what I could gather the programme was taking a bunch of non-christians – and when I say non-christians it was like a politically correct collection of anybody and everybody who could be as far removed from the stereotypical christian portrayed in the media – and trying to MAKE them a Christian through exposing them to different aspects of Christianity. They were being ‘mentored’ and taken to various places around Leeds and the rest of the country to see if they could be ‘convinced’ to give Christianity a go…
Well to be honest – something just didn’t sit right in my spirit – it was one of those ‘no peace’ moments and so we made our excuses and left them to it.
Tonight the show aired in a prime evening slot on Channel 4. I just watched and thank God we didn’t get involved. The only thing I feel sorry for is the poor bunch of guys who have been subjected to a literal Bible-bashing…
I’ve just read Bill Hybels amazing book on how to point people towards faith called ‘Just Walk Across the Room‘ – where the main premise of reaching people for Christ is to live life in 3D: 1st Develop Friendships, 2nd Discover common ground Stories, 3rd Discern next steps – all the time keeping your life open to the guidance of the Holy Spirit. However a small proportion of the nation just watched a group of clergy attempt to indoctrinate the poor guinea pigs on the show by telling them what to believe, visiting their home and telling them what they shouldn’t be doing, and then sitting them down in a ‘mentoring’ session and dictating what they need to do to become a Christian.. I’m sorry but there was no grace, no love shown to these people and to be honest – their current lives looked a lot more interesting than the monastery of a life they were being sold.
Now I know that the media is a vicious being when it comes to editing and so I give the clergy involved a degree of grace over the whole thing – but I’m glad we didn’t get involved! The last thing this country needs to see is a documentary that gives them the impression that all Christians want to do is ‘Make them a Christian’ and that means you better lock away anything that might be deemed sinful cause otherwise you’re going to have to burn it all before you can come close to having any relationship with God.
I appreciate that people need to deal with the stuff in their lives. But that’s what Jesus died for – so that God’s grace can be extended FIRST to everyone no matter where you find yourself in life. The dealing with sin has already been dealt with – so first you can enter into relationship and then as God’s love and design for your life is revealed to you the stuff of the old life will be left where it belongs in the past.
Make me a Christian! I think not… Show me a loving Saviour… I think so!
2 Responses to “a close shave with 'Make me a Christian'”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.


















Something tells me that I am glad I did not watch this program. I watched the “Make me a Muslim” version a while back and even that did not sit right with me either.
Sensationalist T.V. at it’s best.
Hmmm…. very interesting. I must admit I watched the program and was left a little puzzled. Couldn’t quite put my finger on waht was Soooooooo wrong.
Then I thought about my own coming to faith…. it is the experience of God’s love for us, the realisation of Jesus’ death on the cross and the movement of the Holy Spirt that has such an impact on the rest of a Christians life. This MUST come first and if this divine intervention is genuine, then sure this will impact on the other areas of life.
It perhaps sounds easy put like this and i know this is not allways the case and as humans it is always easy to fill our lives with things that detract from God.
The shock tactics of extremes disturbed me too…. it apeared to be a clasic case of brainwashing. We must remember not sinning and condeming abortion alone is not what being a Christian is about…. I wonder which episode in the series will meet with Jesus????
I have to agree with Chris on the media point…. I REALLY hope and pray the clergy’s attitudes and approaches were mis represented on the TV program, thankfully the clergy I know certainly would not have used these methods of communication and teaching!
Dave.